Reviews for Some Enchanted Evening

BY : NataliaV

  • From RogueMudblood on August 15, 2011

    I freely admit to having waited before leaving you a review. Though I know this is an old piece, I would be remiss if I didn't give you some feedback on it.

    I read this yesterday, and was actually a little appalled at Creed's actions. I know there are dirty cops, and I know that this is such a "light" example of illegal actions on the part of officers, but his actions are reprehensible. While I know that would be very in character for the Victor Creed of the comics, it does not truly fit with the Creed you've written.

    I admit to not fully understanding why this was not rendered as an original piece. The main two characters have the same names as X-Men canon characters, but other than that, this piece has no basis in fandom. I was surprised to find something that did not at least in some small way tie into the existing universe. The characters could easily be given other names, and this be posted as an original work.

    I appreciate that you put effort into this and shared it. I thank you for that, and happy writing to you.

    Report Review

  • From Demona on March 16, 2005

    Badly Developed.
    Even for a alternate universe fiction, Sabretooth is entirely out of character. And since when did they give mutant's police jobs?
    If you read the comics, you'll notice he doesn't mind prostitutes. He visits a whore house frequently.


    Report Review

  • From ANON - Perry D. on May 18, 2003

    Great stuff! I can't stand Victor for the most part, but I do love the fic. Especially Ororo.

    Report Review